Enki

NYC, LA, Chicago schools weigh leaving Google Search

By

Published

Reporting from The New York Times, The Verge

More onGoogle

Google says schools that block AI altogether lose Google Search too. New York, Los Angeles and Chicago officials say they may switch search engines.

What it means for founders

This is a procurement fight, and the buyers are large. When an incumbent bundles AI into a product customers cannot easily give up, the customers with the most leverage start looking elsewhere. For edtech founders, the opening is a search or research tool that districts can configure, with AI features they can switch off one at a time and logs that satisfy a school board.

The same pattern applies outside schools. Any customer with strict rules on AI, from hospitals to government agencies, will ask whether a vendor's AI can be separated from the core product. If yours can, say so in the sales deck.

Watch whether Google offers an AI-free Search for schools before its change takes effect, and whether any of the three districts actually switches its default engine.

What we don't know yet

Google has said only that the change comes next year, without a date. None of the reporting we read says a district has named a replacement or set a deadline. The dispute is over the AI built into Google Search, such as AI Overviews, not only Google's Gemini.

More Google news on Enki.

The story

Officials at three of the biggest school systems in the United States, in New York City, Chicago and Los Angeles, are weighing alternatives to Google Search after Google said schools that restrict AI altogether would lose Google Search as well. The New York Times reported the districts' positions on Wednesday; this account relies on Gizmodo's summary of that report and on Google's own post.

What Google changed

On November 3, Google said in a blog post that Google Search, Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Gemini in Classroom will be switched off entirely for K-12 students' accounts until an administrator enables them. It framed this as more control for schools, and said it would share details "in the coming months" before the change rolls out.

The catch is that Search now counts as an AI product. "Search and AI are deeply integrated," Chris Phillips, Google's vice president for education, told the Times, adding that students at a school that restricts AI altogether "will not have access to search," TechCrunch reported. As Google has described it so far, TechCrunch wrote, schools that want Google Search "will have to accept its AI features."

The districts push back

New York City schools chancellor Kamar Samuels told the Times that if Google does not reconsider, "we will explore other search options," adding, "We refuse to accept the false binary Google has laid out." Mayor Zohran Mamdani had already accused Google on November 3 of "trying to use its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools." Google replied on X the same day that its announcements "give schools more choice, not less."

In Los Angeles, the district's chief information officer, Jack Kelanic, said at a meeting of the school board's AI committee, "We can change the default search engine literally overnight," the Times reported. Chicago Public Schools said in an email to the Times that it wants a version of Google Search without AI and, failing that, "will look to other search solutions."

Google told the Times that from next year, Search and Gemini will be disabled "until schools decide which services to enable."

Sources

Primary sources

Tools in this story

We may earn a commission if you sign up through our links. It never affects our ratings or which stories we cover.

Gemini

Google's assistant, built into Workspace and Android

8.9Editor’s scoreVisit Gemini

More in Policy & Safety

How Enki covers newsCorrectionsReport an error